>> ASIAONE / HEALTH / WELLNESS @ WORK / STORY
Wed, Jun 24, 2009
my paper
Tried positive thinking? It may make you feel worse

TOSS aside what your shelves of self-help tomes may tell you.

Repeating positive statements, it turns out, may not help boost low self-esteem, a new study has found. It might even make you feel worse, reported the Washington Post.

Professor Joanne Wood of the University of Waterloo in Ontario and two colleagues ran tests in which they got students to repeat statements to themselves, such as "I am a lovable person", charting how their moods changed after doing so.

Those of their subjects - 32 male and 36 female psychology students - who already had low self-esteem did not find any improvement in their mood. Indeed, the gap between those with high and low self-esteem actually grew.

Yet, as the researchers note in an article in Psychological Science journal, self-help books, reaching back at least to 1952's famed The Power Of Positive Thinking by Norman Vincent Peale, have always advised repeating your own supposed strengths to yourself.

"At this moment, thousands of people across North America are probably silently repeating positive statements to themselves," the researchers observed.

The study found that even if the subjects were told to focus on how the statement "I am a lovable person" might be true about themselves, the results did not vary.

This suggests "that for certain people, positive self-statements may not only be ineffective, but actually detrimental", the researchers concluded.

"One possibility is that, like over-positive praise, they can elicit contradictory thoughts."


For more my paper stories click here.

 
 
STORY INDEX
 
  Tried positive thinking? It may make you feel worse
   
 
  Keep H1N1 virus at bay, do away with toilet doors
   
 
  How to keep hydrated in this hot, hot season
   
 
  Keeping blood clots away
   
 
  My sinus lah...
   
 
  Tummy trouble
   
 
  Fried eyes
   
 
  Not practical for GPs to refer all flu cases
   
 
  Slave to a whiskey bottle
   
 
  The key to recovery
   
>> RELATED STORY
Tried positive thinking? It may make you feel worse
Thoughts heal you, kill you
Positive thinking doesn't stop cancer: US scientists

Elsewhere in AsiaOne...

Business: Think positive

 

We welcome contributions, comments and tips.
a1health@sph.com.sg